People who buy books, not counting useful how-to-do-it books, are of two kinds. There are those who buy because they love books and what they can get from them, and those to whom books are one form of entertainment among several. The first group, which is by far the smaller, will go on reading, if not for ever, then for as long as one can foresee. The second group has to be courted. It is the second which makes the best-seller, impelled thereto by the buzz that a particular book is really something special; and it also makes publishers’ headaches, because it has become more and more resistant to courting.How simply this clears up my confusion over 'Why did that become a bestseller?' - or even the concept of the bestseller at all. The second group, as she details later in Stet, would just as happily turn to music or television or cinema for their entertainment. Those of us in the first group (though of course we might well enjoy music, television, and cinema) cannot imagine a substitute for books. Nothing comes close.
Tuesday, 16 April 2013
Diana Athill... on two types of readers
I couldn't find an apt place to include this quotation in my review of Diana Athill's Stet yesterday, but it's so wonderful a quotation that I had to put it up somewhere:
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
A very astute division, I think.
ReplyDeleteThis simple division has made so much sense to me!
DeleteNow isn't that the truth. The descriptions of the two types of readers is defined quite well. Then of course there are the collectors. Where do they come in? :-)
ReplyDeleteI think they belong to the same sort of group as toy collectors - the latter look for blemish-free toys in their original boxes. Their value is in the resale price - God forbid they should have been played with!
DeleteWith books - could it be the ones with un-cut pages? Arrgghh!
Collectors who don't read don't factor in my equation! I have a horror of them...
DeleteI adore this quotation, and agree with it completely. I'm so often made fun of because I seldom enjoy a movie made from a favorite book. There is no comparison when it comes to my choice of entertainment. Thanks for sharing.
ReplyDeleteWe're amongst friends here, aren't we, Bonnie? I forget sometimes how the outside world doesn't always sympathise!
DeleteThis is a great quote and it explains "The Da Vinci Code", "50 Shades of Grey" and numerous others.
ReplyDeleteDoesn't it just! And how sometimes great books can get to the masses too, through the same processes.
DeleteIt also explains why it is so difficult to predict what is going to be the 'next big thing'. Such readers are more likely to be swayed by non-literary considerations.
ReplyDeleteSo true!
DeleteI completely agree with her.
ReplyDeleteShe's so wise!
DeleteIt's also referred to as the 45% and it's what made 50 shades such a phenomenal best-seller. The 45% are the people who generally don't read books, but when something gets talked about 'word of mouth' that they should absolutely try, they respond. They are the people who heard about the book at the hair salon and told their girl-friends and many of them read it before it was published in the mainstream. It also explains why ordinary readers just didn't get what all the fuss was about. It's a fascinating subject. I admit I never read any of the books, but I really enjoyed listening to those who did, particularly the normally non-readers. Almost impossible to predict what will spark the next phenomena like this.
ReplyDeleteIsn't it a fascinating topic? The bestseller is so different from other types of sellers.
DeleteI think that's a really apt quotation. We'd all like to think of ourselves as the first group, but I think we can all sometimes see that we have a part of the second group in us as well. We try and hunt those literary nuggets of gold in smaller bookshops, but sometimes we follow the crowd too, and buy a best seller from Whsmiths. readingmeandknowingyou.blogspot.com
ReplyDeleteThat's interesting! I actively avoid bestsellers, but sometimes catch myself up on that, and try to avoid the snobbery...
DeleteI am pleased to be in the first group and intend to stay there.
ReplyDeleteAmen!
DeleteLikewise Cynthia - couldn't do without books. What a great quote, Simon!
ReplyDeleteIsn't it great? Athill really illuminated a lot for me there.
DeleteThat is a fantastic quote and it really does explain why certain books become such blockbusters. I was thinking about this post this morning as I drove to work. I have always read books, but in the past six or so years, as my reading and interest in books has increased (thanks in great part to book blogs!), I have almost completely stopped watching television and movies.
ReplyDeleteI wish I could say that I didn't watch much TV - but I seem to watch so much, still... those darn soap operas take up my time ;)
DeleteAptly put, some turn against the general thinking because they see the literary merit of a published literature, while the more mainstream gets swayed because an authority has told - akin to herds attracted to a fancy watering hole.
ReplyDeleteA nice image!
Delete